The Meaning of Michael Phelps
In today’s New York Times, commentary on the emergence of Michael Phelps as icon for kids with attention deficit disorder, and how people perceive ADHD and other disorders:
On the one hand:
The notion that a disability can be harnessed in a positive way is not a new concept. Last year, a study found that 35 percent of the small-business entrepreneurs surveyed identified themselves as dyslexic. The researchers concluded that dyslexia made them better communicators and problem solvers, more likely to delegate authority.
…
“We want to tell children, ‘You’ve got a difference, but not a disease,’ ” he said. “Michael Phelps is one of any thousands of examples of mega-successful people, C.E.O.s and brain surgeons and famous writers, inventors and entrepreneurs, who have A.D.H.D.”
On the other:
Other experts, however, say that while such success stories can be inspiring, parents need to know that their children face real risks. Research shows that children with attention deficit have different brain patterns from other children, and that they are more likely to drop out of school, be involved in car accidents and use illicit drugs.
…
Ms. Knochenhauer, who has four children with the disorder, says they too were inspired by the astonishing performance of Mr. Phelps in Beijing. But she added, “I would argue that Michael Phelps is a great swimmer with A.D.H.D., but he’s not a great swimmer because he has A.D.H.D.”
Dr. Koplewicz, of N.Y.U., agreed. “There are lots of children in the world who have chronic illnesses or disorders like diabetes, allergies or dyslexia who accomplish great things in spite of the fact that they have these disorders,” he said. “I worry when we say A.D.H.D. is a gift, that this minimizes how real it is.”
Tara Parker-Pope, A New Face for ADHD. And a Debate, New York Times, 24 November 2008.
I like Hallowell’s comment that ADHD ought be considered a “trait”, with all the pluses, minuses, and non-relevants that a trait can be. As for the research into small business, the 35% dyslexic number is shockingly high to me. I’ve wanted to do a similar survey for small business owners and ADHD. If anyone would like to fund it, please email me!

Mental coach Dr. Richard Coop has worked with numerous top athletes, including the late Payne Stewart*. Here’s an excerpt from an interview with Chapel Hill Magazine: